Аннотації

Автор(и):
Тулупов М.О.
Автор(и) (англ)
Tulupov Mikhail
Дата публікації:

21.08.2019

Анотація (укр):

Забезпечення результативності, ефективності, керованості реалізації цілей та видів діяльності в умовах конкуренції потребує для їх підтримки застосування відповідних додатків, їх інтеграції в єдину інформаційну систему (ІС) для інтегрованого управління підприємством. ІС управління проектами (УП) є складовою єдиної ІС, будується для реалізації цілей інвестиційної діяльності. Для її побудови на практиці застосовують: модуль УП ERP, програмне забезпечення з УП, обидва додатки ізольовано або інтегровано. Доцільність інтеграції цих додатків пов'язана з: несумісністю їх інформаційних технологій; різною повнотою реалізації функціоналу УП та його відповідністю вимогам світових стандартів; наявністю зв'язку даних та видів діяльності в системі управління підприємством; неефективністю процесів УП через недоліки функціоналу УП ERP, ізольовану експлуатацію додатків та дублювання їх функцій і даних, ручне перенесення даних. Тому актуальним та своєчасним є застосування знань в галузі інтеграції додатків підприємства. Результатами дослідження є класифікації знань та інструментів у цій галузі. Класифікації пропонується застосовувати в проектах побудови ІС УП та в інших проектах інтеграції додатків підприємства.

Анотація (рус):

Обеспечение результативности, эффективности, управляемости реализации целей и видов деятельности в условиях конкуренции требует для их поддержки применения соответствующих приложений, интеграции приложений в единую информационную систему (ИС) для интегрированного управления предприятием. ИС управления проектами (УП) является частью единой ИС, строится для реализации целей инвестиционной деятельности. Для ее построения на практике применяются: модуль УП ERP, программное обеспечение УП, оба приложения изолированно или интегрированно. Целесообразность интеграции этих приложений связана с: несовместимостью их информационных технологий; разной полнотой реализации функционала УП и его соответствием требованиям мировых стандартов УП; наличием связи данных и видов деятельности в общей системе управления предприятием; неэффективностью процессов УП из-за недостатков функционала УП ERP, изолированной эксплуатации приложений, дублирования функций и данных, ручного переноса данных. Поэтому актуальным и своевременным является применение знаний в области интеграции приложений предприятия. Результатами исследования являются классификации знаний и инструментов в этой области. Классификации предлагается применять в проектах построения ИС УП и в других проектах интеграции приложений предприятия.

Анотація (англ):

Ensuring the effectiveness, efficiency, manageability of the implementation of goals and kind of activities in a market competition requires for their support the use of relevant applications, the integration of applications into a single information system (IS) for integrated enterprise management. PMIS is part of a single IS and is construct to implement the objectives of investment activities in the form of projects, programs and portfolios. For its construction in the world practice are used: Project Management (PM) module of ERP, PM software, both applications are isolated or integrated. The expediency of PMIS construction based on the integration of these applications is justified by the following reasons:1) the data and activities supported by the applications are related in the enterprise management system; 2) the incompatibility of information technologies in the applications; 3) the PM module of ERP has disadvantages of PM functionality in comparison with PM Software; 4) isolated using of applications leads to inefficiency of PM processes, duplication of functions and data, manual copying and re-entry of data between applications. Therefore, the use of knowledge in the enterprise application integration (EAI) area is relevant and timely. The results of the research are the development of knowledge and tools classifications in the EAI area: types of integration, approaches, technologies, methods, types of integrable applications, middleware. Also systematized EAI tools selection criteria. Classifications are proposed to apply for a more rationales choice of knowledge and EAI tools in projects for the construction of PMIS, in other EAI projects.

Література:

  1. Kähkönen Tommi What Do We Know About ERP Integration? [Text] / Tommi Kähkönen, Andrey Maglyas, Kari Smolander // Enterprise Information Systems. Revised Selected Papers of the 15th International Conference ICEIS 2013, Angers, France, July 4 – 7, 2013. Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing / Slimane Hammoudi, José Cordeiro, Leszek A. Maciaszek, Filipe Joaquim (Eds). Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing, 2014. Vol. 190. P. 51 67. http://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-09492-2_4. ISSN 1865-1348, ISBN 978-3-319-09491-5.
  2. Шехватов Дмитрий. Информационная поддержка проектно-ориентированной бизнес-модели [Электронный ресурс] / Дмитрий Шехватов // Рациональное управление предприятием. 2011. №3. С. 28 78. Режим доступа: http://www.remmag.ru/admin/upload_data/remmag/11-3/IFS.pdf.
  3. Gulliksen Thomas Interoperability between ERP System and Project Planning System [Electronic resource]: Master’s Thesis: Department of Civil and Transport Engineering / Thomas Gulliksen. Oslo, Norway: Norwegian University of Science and Technology, 2012. 70 p. Retrieved from: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/52097667.pdf.
  4. Ghai Carrie White paper. Capturing project cost in project ERP [Electronic resource] / Carrie Ghai. USA: IFS AB, 2012. 8 p. Retrieved from: https://www.ifsworld.com/ua/-/media/assets/2014/09/22/11/38/white-papers-capturing-project-cost-in-project-erp.ashx.
  5. Зуев Михаил PM Expert Project Management Consulting. Результаты опроса «Информационные системы управления проектами – опыт внедрения и использования» [Электронный ресурс] / Михаил Зуев. М.: ЗАО «ПМ Эксперт», 2012. 13 c. Режим доступа: http://www.pmexpert.ru/library/material/isup2011report_demo.pdf.
  6. Управление проектами: учебное пособие для студентов, обучающихся по специальности «Менеджмент организаций» [Текст] / И.И. Мазур, В.Д. Шапиро, Н.Г. Ольдерогге [и др.]. Под общ. ред. И.И. Мазура и В.Д. Шапиро.
    6-е изд., стер. М.: Издательство «Омега-Л», 2010. 960 с.: ил., табл. (Современное бизнес-образование).
    ISBN 978-5-370-01058-3.
  7. Ilyas M.A.B. PMIS: boon or bane? [Electronic resource] / M.A.B. Ilyas, M.K. Hassan, M.U. Ilyas // PMI® Global Congress 2013 – EMEA, Istanbul, Turkey, April 22 – 24, 2013. Newtown Square, PA, USA: Project Management Institute Inc., 2013. Retrieved from: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/project-management-information-systems-overviews-5813.
  8. Rathmann Charles, Jutras Sindy How well does ERP facilitate project based business models? [Electronic resource] / Charles Rathmann, Sindy Jutras. USA: IFS North America, Mint Jutras, 2012. 24 p. Retrieved from: https://www.slideshare.net/charlesrathmann1/how-well-does-erp-facilitate-project-based-business-models.
  9. Tenhiälä Antti Solutions for project-based manufacturing [Electronic resource] / Antti Tenhiälä // OM in the New World Uncertainties. Papers of the 17th Annual Conference of the Production and Operations Management Society (POMS), Massachusetts, Boston, USA, April 28 – May 1, 2006. Retrieved from: https://www.pomsmeetings.org/confpapers/004/004-0136.pdf.
  10. Tulupov M.A. Problem analysis of Project Management Information System Construction at Iron and Steel Enterprises of Ukraine / M.A. Tulupov // International Scientific Journal. Science. Business. Society. 2016. Year 1, issue 2. P. 25 – 28. ISSN 2367-8380.
  11. Cabanis-Brewin J. ERP: integrating project management into the enterprise [Electronic resource] / J. Cabanis-Brewin // PM Network. 1999. Vol. 13, no. 2. P. 29 – 32. ISSN 1930-4390. Retrieved from: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/enterprise-resource-planning-project-management-10719.
  12. Stolovitsky Neil WHITE PAPER. PPM and ERP Integration Guide: Strategies for software integrations in project-centric organizations [Electronic resource] / Neil Stolovitsky. Genius Inside Inc., 2013. 8 p. Retrieved from: http://project-management.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Successful-PPM-and-ERP-Integration-Strategies.pdf.
  13. Тулупов М.А. Стратегии создания системы управления проектами на металлургических предприятиях Украины [Текст] / М.А. Тулупов // Управління розвитком складних систем. 2018. № 34. С. 58 – 67. ISSN 2412-9933.
  14. Lakade A.A. Project Management Approach Using Erp And Primavera In Construction Industry [Electronic resource] / A.A. Lakade, A.K. Gupta, D.B. Desai // IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IOSR-JMCE). 2013. Vol. 1/5, special issue. P. 21 – 24. ISSN 2278-1684. (Research Papers of the Second International Conference on Emerging Trends in Engineering' 2013. Civil Group. / Dr. J.J. Magdum (Ed), College of Engineering, Jaysingpur). Retrieved from: http://iosrjournals.org/iosr-jmce/papers/sicete(civil)-volume1/5.pdf.
  15. SAP. Группа компаний ПМСОФТ [Электронный ресурс]. Режим доступа: http://www.pmsoft.ru/services/integration/sap/
  16. Georgantzis Stavros The Global Deployment of ERP – Integrated Enterprise Project Management Systems (v.3.0) [Electronic resource] / Stavros Georgantzis. USA: TPG The Project Group GmbH, 2013. 7 p. Retrieved from: http://www.theprojectgroup.com/fileadmin/web_data/public-data/downloads/Fachartikel/Global_Deployment_of_ERP-integrated_EPM_systems_2012_TPGA-TheProjectGroupAmerica_2013.pdf.
  17. Zhao Songzheng. Research on an Information Integration Framework on the Large Complex Product Development PMIS with ERP [Text] / Songzheng Zhao, Ming Yin // Advances in Materials Manufacturing Science and Technology II: Selected and peer-reviewed papers of the 12th International Manufacturing Conference in China, September 21 – 23, 2006, Northwestern Polytechnic University, Xi'an, China / Jiang Chengyu, Liu Geng, Zhang Dinghua, Xu Xipeng (Eds). Zurich, Switzerland: Trans Tech Publications Ltd, 2007. Vol. 532 533, P. 917 – 920. http://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/msf.532-533.917. ISBN10 0878494219, ISBN13 9780878494217.
  18. Ingram Kenny Project Portfolio Management vs Project ERP [Electronic resource] / Kenny Ingram. USA: IFS AB, 2013. 7 p. Retrieved from: http://www.ifsworld.com/ua/--/media/assets/2014/07/16/15/57/white-papers-project-portfolio-management-versus-erp.ashx.
  19. Themistocleous Marinos G. Evaluating the Adoption of Enterprise Application Integration in Multinational Organizations [Electronic resource]: A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy: Department of Information Systems and Computing / Marinos G. Themistocleous. London, United Kingdom: Brunel University, 2002. 316 p. Retrieved from: https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/5524/1/FulltextThesis.pdf.
  20. Themistocleous Marinos Towards a Novel Framework for the Assessment of Enterprise Application Integration Packages [Text] / Marinos Themistocleous, Zahir Irani // Proceedings of the 36th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS-36), Big Island, Hawaii, USA, January 6 – 9, 2003 / Ralph H. Sprague, Jr. (Eds). Los Alamitos, California, USA: IEEE Computer Society Washington, DC., 2003. Vol. 8. P. 234.1. http://doi.org/10.1109/HICSS.2003.1174608. ISBN 0-7695-1874-5.
  21. Lam Wing An Enterprise Application Integration (EAI) Case-Study: Seamless Mortgage Processing at Harmond Bank [Text] / Wing Lam // Journal of Computer Information Systems. 2005. Vol. 46, issue 1. P. 35 – 43. https://doi.org/10.1080/08874417.2005.11645867.
  22. Xu Li Da Enterprise Integration and Information Architecture. A Systems Perspective on Industrial Information Integration [Text] / Li Da Xu. New York, USA: Auerbach Publications, 2014. 446 p. (Advances in Systems Science and Engineering series). https://doi.org/10.1201/b17156. ISBN 978-1-4398-5024-4.
  23. Molina Arturo Enterprise Integration and Networking: Challenges and Trends [Text] / Arturo Molina, Hervé Panetto, David Chen, Lawrence Whitman, Vincent Chapurlat, François Vernadat // Studies in Informatics and Control. Bucharest, Romania: Informatics and Control Publications, 2007. Vol. 16, issue 4. P. 353 – 368. ISSN 1220-1766.
  24. Molina Arturo Enterprise Integration and Networking: Issues, Trends and Vision [Text] / Arturo Molina, David Chen, Herve Panetto, Larry Whitman // Knowledge Sharing in the Integrated Enterprise. Interoperability Strategies for the Enterprise Architect. Proceedings of International Working Conference on the Design of Information Infrastructure Systems for Manufacturing (DIISM 2004), International Conference on Enterprise Integration and Modeling Technology (ICEIMT 2004), Toronto, Canada, October 9 – 11, 2004. IFIP – The International Federation for Information Processing / Peter Bernus, Mark Fox (Eds). Berlin, Germany: Springer, Boston, MA, 2005. Vol. 183. P. 303 – 313. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-29766-9_25. ISBN 978-0-387-26608-4.
  25. Liu X. Manufacturing perspective of enterprise application integration: the state of the art review [Text] / X. Liu, W.J. Zhang, R. Radhakrishnan, Y.L. Tu // International Journal of Production Research. 2008. Vol. 46, no. 16. P. 4567 – 4596. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00207540701263325. ISSN 1366-588X.
  26. Enterprise Application Integration – An Overview [Electronic resource]. India: Goldstone Technologies Limited. 14 p. Retrieved from: http://www.goldstonetech.com/investor%20info/white%20papers/EAI%20Overview.pdf.
  27. He Wu Integration of Distributed Enterprise Applications: A Survey [Text] / Wu He, Li Da Xu // IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics. 2014. Vol. 10, no. 1. P. 35–42. https://doi.org/doi:10.1109/tii.2012.2189221.
  28. Тулупов М.О. Класифікація підходів, технологій і методів інтеграції програмного забезпечення з метою побудови інформаційної системи управління проектами [Текст] / М.О. Тулупов // Збірник матеріалів міжнародної науково-практичної інтернет-конференції «Управління проектами. Ефективне використання результатів наукових досліджень та об’єктів інтелектуальної власності», 21 – 22 березня 2019 р., НМетАУ, УКРНЕТ, НДІІВ НАПрН України, м. Дніпро, Україна. Дніпро: Юрсервіс, Київ: Інтерсервіс, 2019. Т. 1. С. 75 77.
  29. White Colin A roadmap to enterprise data integration [Electronic resource] / Colin White. USA: BI Research, IBM Corporation, 2006. 30 p. Retrieved from: ftp://public.dhe.ibm.com/software/emea/de/db2/A-Roadmap-To-Enterprise-Data-Integration.pdf.
  30. Тулупов М.О. Класифікація та вибір інструментів інтеграції додатків підприємства з метою побудови інформаційної системи управління проектами [Текст] / М.О. Тулупов // Тези доповідей XVІ Міжнародної науково-практичної конференції "Управління проектами у розвитку суспільства". Тема: «Управління проектами в умовах очікування глобальних змін», 17-18 травня 2019 р., м. Київ, Україна.‒ К.: КНУБА, 2019.‒ С. 212 – 214.

 

References:

  1. Kähkönen, Tommi, Maglyas, Andrey & Smolander, Kari. (2014). What Do We Know About ERP Integration? In: Slimane, Hammoudi, José, Cordeiro, Leszek A., Maciaszek, Filipe Joaquim (Eds). Enterprise Information Systems. Revised Selected Papers of the 15th International Conference, ICEIS 2013, Angers, France, July 4–7, 2013. Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing. (Vol. 190), 51–67. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-09492-2_4 [in English].
  2. Shehvatov, Dmitriy. (2011). Information support for a project-based business model. Enterprise management rational, (Vol. 3), 28–31. Retrieved from: http://www.remmag.ru/admin/upload_data/remmag/11-3/IFS.pdf [in Russian].
  3. Gulliksen, Thomas. (2012). Interoperability between ERP System and Project Planning System. Master’s Thesis. Department of Civil and Transport Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Oslo, Norway, 70. Retrieved from: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/52097667.pdf [in English].
  4. Ghai, Carrie. (2012). White paper. Capturing project cost in project ERP. USA: IFS AB, 8. Retrieved from: https://www.ifsworld.com/ua/-/media/assets/2014/09/22/11/38/white-papers-capturing-project-cost-in-project-erp.ashx [in English].
  5. Zuyev, Mikhail. (2012). PM Expert Project Management Consulting. The results of the survey «Project management information systems – experience of implementation and use». Moscow, Russia: CJSC «PM Expert», 13. Retrieved from: http://www.pmexpert.ru/library/material/isup2011report_demo.pdf [in Russian].
  6. Mazur, I.I. & Shapiro, V.D. (Eds), Olderogge, N.G. & Polkovnikov A.V. (2010). Project management: a tutorial for students studying in the specialty «Management of Organizations» (6th ed.). Moscow, Russia: «Omega-L» Publishing, 960.
  7. Ilyas M.A.B., Hassan M.K. & Ilyas M.U. (2013). PMIS: boon or bane? Papers of the PMI® Global Congress 2013 – EMEA, Istanbul, Turkey, April 22–24, 2013. Newtown Square, PA USA: Project Management Institute, Inc. Retrieved from: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/project-management-information-systems-overviews-5813 [in English].
  8. Rathmann, Charles & Jutras, Sindy. (2012). How well does ERP facilitate project based business models? USA: IFS North America, Mint Jutras, 24. Retrieved from: https://www.slideshare.net/charlesrathmann1/how-well-does-erp-facilitate-project-based-business-models[in English].
  9. Tenhiälä, Antti. (2006). Solutions for project-based manufacturing. OM in the New World. Papers of the 17th Annual Conference of the Production and Operations Management Society (POMS), Massachusetts, Boston, USA, April 28–May 1, 2006. Retrieved from: https://www.pomsmeetings.org/confpapers/004/004-0136.pdf [in English].
  10. Tulupov, M.A. (2016). Problem analysis of project management information system construction at iron and steel enterprises of Ukraine. International scientific journal. Science. Business. Society, (Year 1, issue 2), 25–28 [in English].
  11. Cabanis-Brewin, J. (1999). ERP: integrating project management into the enterprise. PM Network, (Vol. 13, no. 2), 29–32. Retrieved from: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/enterprise-resource-planning-project-management-10719. [in English].
  12. Stolovitsky, Neil. (2013). WHITE PAPER. PPM and ERP Integration Guide: Strategies for software integrations in project-centric organizations. Genius Inside Inc., 8. Retrieved from: http://project-management.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Successful-PPM-and-ERP-Integration-Strategies.pdf [in English].
  13. Tulupov, Mikhail. (2018). Strategies for creation of the project management system at the metallurgical enterprises of Ukraine. Management of Development of Complex Systems, (Vol. 34), 58–67 [in Russian].
  14. Lakade, A.A., Gupta, A.K., Desai, D.B. (2013). A project management approach using erp and primavera in construction industry. In: Magdum J.J. (Ed). Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Emerging Trends in Engineering. Civil Group. In: IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IOSR-JMCE), (Vol. 1/5, Special Issue), 21-24. Retrieved from: http://iosrjournals.org/iosr-jmce/papers/sicete(civil)-volume1/5.pdf [in English].
  15. SAP. PMSOFT Group of Companies. Retrieved from: http://www.pmsoft.ru/services/integration/sap/ [in Russian].
  16. Georgantzis, Stavros. (2013). The Global Deployment of ERP – Integrated Enterprise Project Management Systems (v3.0). USA: TPG The Project Group GmbH, 7. Retrieved from: http://www.theprojectgroup.com/fileadmin/web_data/public-data/downloads/Fachartikel/Global_Deployment_of_ERP-integrated_EPM_systems_2012_TPGA-TheProjectGroupAmerica_2013.pdf [in English].
  17. Zhao, Songzheng & Yin, Ming. (2006). Research on an Information Integration Framework on the Large Complex Product Development PMIS with ERP. In: Jiang Chengyu, Liu Geng, Zhang Dinghua, Xu Xipeng (Eds). Advances in Materials Manufacturing Science and Technology II: Selected and peer-reviewed papers of the 12th International Manufacturing Conference in China, Northwestern Polytechnic University, Xi'an, China, September 21–23, 2006, (Vol. 532-533), 917–920. Zurich, Switzerland: Trans Tech Publications Ltd. Retrieved from: http://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/msf.532-533.917 [in English].
  18. Ingram, Kenny. (2013). Project Portfolio Management vs Project ERP. USA: IFS AB, 7. Retrieved from: http://www.ifsworld.com/ua/--/media/assets/2014/07/16/15/57/white-papers-project-portfolio-management-versus-erp.ashx [in English].
  19. Themistocleous, Marinos G. (2002). Evaluating the Adoption of Enterprise Application Integration in Multinational  Organizations. A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Department of Information Systems and Computing, Brunel University, London, United Kingdom, 316. Retrieved from: https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/5524/1/FulltextThesis.pdf [in English].
  20. Themistocleous, Marinos & Irani, Zahir. (2003). Towards a Novel Framework for the Assessment of Enterprise Application Integration Packages. In: Ralph H. Sprague, Jr. (Eds). Proceedings of the 36th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS-36), Big Island, Hawaii, USA, January 6–9, 2003, (Vol. 8), 234.1. Los Alamitos, California, USA: IEEE Computer Society Washington, DC. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1109/HICSS.2003.1174608. ISBN 0-7695-1874-5 [in English].
  21. Lam, Wing. (2005). An Enterprise Application Integration (EAI) Case-Study: Seamless Mortgage Processing at Harmond Bank. Journal of Computer Information Systems, (Vol. 46, issue 1), 35–43. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1080/08874417.2005.11645867 [in English].
  22. Xu, Li, Da. (2014). Enterprise Integration and Information Architecture. A Systems Perspective on Industrial Information Integration. Advances in Systems Science and Engineering series. New York, USA: Auerbach Publications, 446. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1201/b17156.
  23. Molina, Arturo, Panetto, Hervé, Chen, David, Whitman, Lawrence, Chapurlat, Vincent & Vernadat, François. (2007). Enterprise Integration and Networking: Challenges and Trends. Studies in Informatics and Control, (Vol. 16, Issue 4), 353–368. Bucharest, Romania: Informatics and Control Publications [in English].
  24. Molina, Arturo, Chen, David, Panetto, Herve, Whitman, Larry. (2005). Enterprise Integration and Networking: Issues, Trends and Vision. In: Peter Bernus, Mark Fox (Eds). Knowledge Sharing in the Integrated Enterprise. Interoperability Strategies for the Enterprise Architect. Proceedings of the International Working Conference on the Design of Information Infrastructure Systems for Manufacturing (DIISM 2004), International Conference on Enterprise Integration and Modeling Technology (ICEIMT 2004), Toronto, Canada, October 9-11, 2004. IFIP — The International Federation for Information Processing, (Vol. 183), 303–313. Berlin, Germany: Springer, Boston, MA. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-29766-9_25 [in English].
  25. Liu, X., Zhang, W.J., Radhakrishnan, R., Tu, Y.L. (2008). Manufacturing perspective of enterprise application integration: the state of the art review. International Journal of Production Research, (Vol. 46, no. 16). 4567–4596. Retrieved from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00207540701263325 [in English].
  26. Enterprise Application Integration – An Overview. India: Goldstone Technologies Limited, 14. Retrieved from: http://www.goldstonetech.com/investor%20info/white%20papers/EAI%20Overview.pdf [in English].
  27. He, Wu & Xu, Li, Da. (2014). Integration of Distributed Enterprise Applications: A Survey. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, ( Vol. 10, no. 1). 35–42. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/doi:10.1109/tii.2012.2189221.
  28. Tulupov, M.O. (2019). Classification of software integration approaches, technologies and methods with the objective of project management information system construction. In: Proceedings of the international scientific and practical Internet conference «Project Management. Effective Use of Research Results and Intellectual Property Objects», National metallurgical academy of Ukraine, Ukrainian Project Management Association «UKRNET», Scientific-research Institute of Intellectual Property National Academy of Law Science of Ukraine, Dnipro, Ukraine, March 21–22, 2019, (Vol. 1), 75–77. Dnipro, Ukraine: Yurservice, Kyiv, Ukraine: Interservice [in Ukrainian].
  29. White, Colin (2006). A roadmap to enterprise data integration. USA: BI Research, IBM Corporation, 30. Retrieved from: ftp://public.dhe.ibm.com/software/emea/de/db2/A-Roadmap-To-Enterprise-Data-Integration.pdf.
  30. Tulupov, M.O. (2019). Classification and choice of the enterprise applications integration tools with the objective of project management information system construction. In: Project Management in the Perspective of Global Change. Proceedings of the XVII International Scientific and Practical Conference «Project Management in the Development of Society», Kyiv, Ukraine, May 17 – 18, 2019, 212–214. Kyiv, Ukraine: KNUCA [in Ukrainian].